2004 C230K vs 2006 C230 2.5L -- Advice please
 

Hi,

I'm buying my first car in 16 years and would like some advice on 2 cars I'm thinking about. My last car was a 1990 (I think) 190E, which I loved. I like the size of the C Class and am looking at:

1. 2006 C230 2.5L, 47k miles, $17,500 asking price (2 prev. owners, clean Carfax)
2. 2004 C230K, 53k miles, $9,900 asking price (3 prev. owners, clean Carfax)

I drove a 2005 C230K and didn't love the engine as much as the 2.5L, but $7,500 difference ... I'm not sure I care that much. Obviously, the console of the 2004 isn't as beautiful to look at, but are their other problems/issues with the 2004 models that I should be considering? It seems like a real jump in price for 2 years and 6k miles, although I'm guessing the engine type factors in there too.

I drive about 70 miles day total -- mostly interstate. I'd appreciate any thoughts. Thanks!

Allie